View Full Video Script
5:22 min
View Full Video Script
-
Welcome to this month's economic outlook.
-
My name is Natalie Gallagher and I am a principal economist
-
and director at Board.
-
Today I'm going to spend a little bit
-
of time going over the K-shaped dynamic
-
that we're seeing in the US economy,
-
why this presents a key economic risk as we head into 2026.
-
Now, to really start out,
-
when we look at the KS shaped dynamics,
-
which in this instance is primarily centered on the fact
-
that high income consumers continue to spend
-
and really drive the consumption growth
-
that we've been experiencing in the economy, whereas lower
-
and middle income consumers are,
-
are stalling out in terms of economic growth.
-
We have to focus on three key risk profiles.
-
First and foremost, high income consumers
-
or high income households, top 20%, they now drive about 63%
-
of consumer spending growth.
-
That's up from just 55% last year.
-
That's a really concerning acceleration of
-
what we're calling these khap dynamics.
-
Second, middle
-
and lower income households contribute just 37%
-
combined in 2025.
-
That's down from 45% in 2024.
-
What's really driving this is persistent inflation
-
and labor market softness.
-
Those are really constraining
-
discretionary spending for these groups.
-
And most importantly, sort of the critical vulnerability
-
that really ties it all together is the fact
-
that the affluent spending we are seeing
-
and the growth there, is really heavily tied
-
to AI driven asset appreciation
-
that's benefiting these affluent households.
-
Now, as economists, this is a key risk
-
that we're tracking very carefully
-
because it means that growth is not broad-based, right?
-
It's on a very narrow foundation.
-
When we look visually what this looks like by the numbers,
-
what we see is that the top 20% of households by income,
-
they now generate nearly two thirds
-
of all consumer spending growth.
-
We have low income households,
-
they're at less than 10% middle income, 28%.
-
You can see high income there, 63%.
-
And like I said, this creates acute concentration risk
-
as we look at how likely is this growth
-
to be sustainable throughout 2026.
-
Now, we also have to highlight, right,
-
that this isn't really static.
-
This isn't a static number.
-
This is actually accelerating a trend
-
that's accelerating in 2025, um,
-
and anticipated to be quite tricky in 2026.
-
So look at the purple line right here.
-
High income share has risen from
-
around 55% in early 20 24, 60 7% in Q3
-
2025, which is the most recent data that we have.
-
Now, meanwhile, middle and low income contributions,
-
that's gonna be the, the blue lines here.
-
They continue to compress.
-
And this pattern is really consistent
-
with wealth effect driven consumption, which is really
-
where we see these wealth effects taking,
-
taking part in the economic expansion rather than income
-
gains that are allowing for sort of the lower, um,
-
lower income cohorts to also pick up their spending as well.
-
So natural next question is what's driving this?
-
What's allowing for this escalation
-
in affluent household spending?
-
And of course we have to go back
-
to tech, we have to go back to
-
Ai. So when we
-
look at what's really been driving these equity
-
gains, um, the,
-
the purple area shows tech industry performance versus the
-
broader s and p 500.
-
And you can see that tech has dramatically outperformed,
-
especially since 2023, right?
-
The AI boom and high income households,
-
they hold the vast majority of equity wealth.
-
And so when tech rallies their portfolios appreciate,
-
they feel wealthier, they're able to spend more.
-
And this of course is creating
-
that concentrated vulnerability
-
that we've really highlighted throughout
-
the past couple of minutes.
-
Now, of course, in this environment there's plenty of risks,
-
but there's also opportunities.
-
And so from a strategic point
-
of view, what do we need to track?
-
First and foremost, we have a primary downside risk, right?
-
And that's asset market corrections inequities
-
that would disproportionately impact those
-
high income consumers.
-
And that's gonna be a tail risk we're gonna need
-
to monitor very closely in 2026.
-
Second, we're in a, a complex policy environment, right?
-
The fed faces a really difficult trade off.
-
We've talked about this before,
-
but of course if we get further easing, then
-
that risks re-acceleration inflation
-
through these wealth effects that we've talked about.
-
At the same time, we, if we get insufficient accommodation,
-
there are risk to employment deterioration,
-
which is continued to prove quite soft
-
as we get into the heart of 2026.
-
Third, we have sustainability concerns, right?
-
The current expansion, it relies on very narrow drivers
-
rather than broad based gains.
-
And so this really limits durability
-
and increases volatility.
-
So we're building on a narrow foundation. So what can we do?
-
We can monitor priorities, right?
-
We need to track equity, market volatility,
-
housing price trends, consumer credit delinquencies,
-
especially among middle
-
and lower income households as sort
-
of an early warning signal as well
-
as labor market stabilization.
-
And these are really gonna be key leading indicators
-
as we get into 2026
-
and what economic growth really looks like.
-
So in short, growth looks, the baseline is
-
for continued growth in 2026,
-
but of course the foundation is quite fragile.
-
There are key risks that, that we absolutely acknowledge
-
and are tracking as we get into the heart of the year.
-
Um, and if you would like to know more about
-
how board can help facilitate you not only tracking these
-
key risks for your industry,
-
but also your company metrics as well,
-
please reach out and request a demo.
-
That that is all I have for you today.
-
So thank you for listening
-
and I hope you have a wonderful rest of your week.