View Full Video Script
12:13 min
View Full Video Script
-
In today's economic outlook, we are going
-
to discuss the latest labor market release
-
and what it means for the trajectory of the US economy.
-
I'm gonna take this opportunity to walk us
-
through the underlying details
-
that really drive the narrative
-
that this is a fundamental moment for the economy
-
and a shift in the economic trajectory.
-
So to really dive into that, I'm gonna start
-
by looking at the headline metrics
-
that had an overall impact on the market
-
day of the data release.
-
We saw non-farm jobs rise by just 22,000.
-
That was well below the 75,000 consensus estimate
-
of be totally transparent.
-
It was below our own estimate, which was closer to 62,000.
-
Now the unemployment rate also ticked up from 4.2% to 4.3%.
-
It was really only part of the story.
-
So when we look at broader measures of unemployment
-
and underemployment, for example,
-
the use six rate from the Bureau of Labor Statistics,
-
which includes not only those who are unemployed
-
but also discouraged workers as well as those
-
who are working part-time for economic reasons,
-
there was a jump up to 8.1%,
-
which is actually the highest level we've seen since
-
October, 2021.
-
Uh, this isn't just a week month of data.
-
The release in conjunction
-
with the significant downward revisions last month implies
-
that we're seeing sustained deceleration
-
that began in April.
-
And the three month average job creation is now running at a
-
low of around 29,000.
-
And that's pretty much recession level low.
-
That's really, really dour
-
for the overall economic environment.
-
Perhaps the most shocking is
-
that June employment was also revised down into negative
-
territory showing the labor market has been weaker than we
-
initially anticipated, even facing the first period in terms
-
of month over month contraction since 2020.
-
Now, what makes this particularly concerning is the fact
-
that it's not just one industry
-
really leading the charge here.
-
It's actually the breadth of the industries
-
that are contributing to the unfortunate jobs reading
-
that we just received, as well as
-
that we've been receiving now for a few months
-
with those downward revisions.
-
And this tells us that the softening isn't really more
-
of a onetime anomaly and one month anomaly,
-
but it's more of a trend
-
that is proving unfortunately persistent.
-
And we see this particularly when we dive in to the sector
-
by sector breakdown.
-
So to look at this data more, more in detail,
-
what we see is that there's a clear divide between
-
what people need and what businesses are willing
-
to invest in and how we see
-
that playing out in the overall employment numbers.
-
So to start with the resilience side,
-
essential services added 58,000 jobs
-
and this was really led by healthcare
-
and education with 46 positions added.
-
Now this makes sense because people still need medical care,
-
they still need education regardless
-
of economic uncertainty.
-
We also saw a bit
-
of a bright spot on on the headline level when we look at
-
consumer discretionary sectors like leisure and hospitality
-
and retail where we saw 38,500 jobs added.
-
But this likely reflects continued recovery towards pre
-
pandemic employment levels rather than a response
-
to robust consumer demand as both
-
of these sectors remain in terms of employment well
-
below their pre COVID trends.
-
So looks very positive on, on first pass,
-
but when we actually dive into the underlying data trends,
-
see that it's more about normalization,
-
less about robust performance, when we shift
-
to a more troubling aspect, the productive economy, we see
-
that there is some contraction,
-
meaningful contraction that's occurring.
-
So goods production and trade shed over 30,000 jobs.
-
Um, unfortunately, manufacturing, wholesale, trade
-
and construction all declined on a month over month basis.
-
We also saw business infrastructure services.
-
The, the backbone of corporate activity
-
cut about 21,000 positions
-
with professional business services
-
really leading the decline there.
-
Now, unsurprisingly,
-
government also pulled back cutting 16,000 jobs on net.
-
So government is a conglomerate of state, federal,
-
and local, but the cut was primarily driven
-
by the federal work force reductions.
-
Now when we see this sort of sector by sector analysis,
-
when we see the overall arching picture,
-
what really comes top of mind is the fact
-
that this is not just one
-
or two sectors that is facing hardship.
-
This is really broad based
-
and what we see with the private sector numbers in the
-
government numbers is that private sector weakness
-
is coming at a time or in tandem with also fiscal restraint.
-
So neither the private
-
or public sphere is really making up in terms of job games
-
or um, overall spend.
-
When we look at the economy as a, as an aggregate,
-
this pattern becomes exactly what we would anticipate
-
with an economic inflection point, right?
-
We have essential services which is quite robust.
-
We have some interesting dynamics when we look at overall
-
consumer consumer spending or discretionary dynamics.
-
And then of course we have a lot
-
of month over month contraction
-
and other employment metrics which are really core
-
to the overall production side of the economy.
-
Taken together. This labor market data really implies
-
that the Federal Reserve is in a very
-
tricky position, right?
-
So last month we talked a lot about
-
what we're seeing in the overall trajectory when it comes
-
to the inflation numbers.
-
We see really sticky services inflation,
-
we're seeing reaccelerating goods, inflation.
-
Neither of those things are great to see.
-
On the other hand, we now have back
-
to back labor market reports, which show quite a lot
-
of weakness, especially when it it
-
comes to our hiring numbers.
-
And this puts the fed in a really difficult position
-
because they have a dual mandate.
-
They not only need to seek price stability,
-
they also need to sort of ensure that we are as close
-
to full employment as we can get.
-
So what that really means in practice is
-
that we want both price stability as well
-
as labor market resiliency.
-
Powell specifically noted in his Jackson Hole speech
-
that the shifting balance of risks may warrant adjustments
-
to the Federal Reserve's policy stance.
-
And that balance has absolutely shifted decisively in these
-
last two labor releases.
-
The sectoral breakdown
-
that we've just discussed really reinforces this case.
-
We're seeing employment contraction
-
and business investment heavy areas
-
and production while only really essential services are
-
holding up in a meaningful way.
-
And this pattern typically requires monetary support
-
to prevent a deeper economic retreat.
-
So even with core inflation running at 3.1%,
-
which is a full percentage point above the fed's, 2% target
-
the magnitude of labor market softening
-
that we're seeing creates a very clear case
-
for accommodation from the Federal Reserve.
-
Now as mentioned, the Fed's dual mandate requires 'em
-
to balance price stability with full employment.
-
So today's report suggests that they're going to
-
be in a position where they'll feel the need
-
to prioritize supporting the labor market, especially given
-
that wage growth remains relatively modest at 3.7%.
-
So why I call that out is
-
because if we saw a pickup in wage gains, this would
-
or could potentially create concern that if we cut rates
-
or if we're a little bit too accommodative,
-
we may get ourselves embroiled in a wage price spiral.
-
The wage data that's coming out currently
-
and the trend that we're seeing doesn't
-
support this concern.
-
And so this puts the Federal Reserve in a little bit of a,
-
a better position to be accommodative moving forward.
-
Now, regardless of all of this,
-
as I noted a few a few minutes
-
before, it doesn't change the fact
-
that the Fed is in the midst of a
-
complex policy puzzle, right?
-
They're sort of facing some mild statuary concerns.
-
We've been talking about this a lot, especially since May
-
where we have a weakening labor market,
-
we have reaccelerating inflation, we have
-
below trend economic growth.
-
And what that looks like
-
for the Federal Reserve is quite a tricky picture
-
as they have to be very intentional in
-
how they thread the needle for monetary policy.
-
Now the Fed needs
-
to support employment while managing inflation expectations
-
and that's what makes it so difficult.
-
Now, based on today's data, they'll clearly err on the side
-
of gross support in the short term.
-
But this sets up potential challenges if inflation
-
accelerates further or if inflation expectations
-
become meaningfully unor
-
for the broader economy.
-
This suggests that we're transitioning from the post
-
pandemic boom to really a lower gross equilibrium.
-
Now, as I mentioned, when we have sort
-
of these stagflationary elements,
-
it's particularly challenging for the Fed, the far cry from
-
where we were in the 1970s,
-
but it is still quite the policy conundrum as Powell
-
and the rest of the FOMC board really seek
-
to keep inflation under control while also seeking
-
to be accommodative, given the flashing signals
-
that the labor market is really, um,
-
really giving us as economists.
-
With all of that in mind, a very tricky situation, right?
-
Very unenviable position for the Federal Reserve.
-
But if I could really leave you
-
with three key takeaways about what this means
-
for the economic trajectory as we make our way into the end
-
of 2025 and into 2026, first
-
and foremost, a September rate cut is more likely than not.
-
This point in time, it almost feels a little bit inevitable
-
and it's really the start
-
of an easing cycle rather than a one-off adjustment.
-
So markets should expect additional cuts likely in December
-
at 25 basis points
-
and potentially into 2026
-
as we move towards a more neutral federal funds rate.
-
Second, this report
-
validates the feds shift from being mildly restrictive
-
to more accommodative.
-
So Powell's Jackson Hole framework now has empirical backing
-
and the employment mandate will take precedence over
-
inflation concerns.
-
Now, I say this with a big caveat,
-
but that is for now, right?
-
It's gonna be really, really interesting
-
and important to watch
-
how the economy responds moving forward to price pressures
-
as well as how the labor market continues
-
to play out over the next several months.
-
Third, the US economy has fundamentally shifted momentum.
-
Most likely we are not in a recession at this time,
-
but we are clearly in a deceleration phase that is going
-
to require policy support.
-
So the soft landing that we were on track
-
for nine months ago,
-
absolutely evolving into something a bit more complex,
-
a meaningful slowdown with stagflationary elements
-
that are absolutely going to test policymakers ability
-
to balance competing objectives
-
for companies navigating this transition.
-
What this looks like is focusing on operational efficiency
-
and cash preservation while positioning
-
for opportunities in resilient sectors.
-
So the sectoral divide
-
that we've seen today suggest businesses should prioritize
-
investments in essential services
-
where they can while deferring non-critical expansion
-
until economic momentum stabilizes.
-
What this looks like in practice is actively monitoring
-
real-time data, engaging in active scenario planning,
-
and then being very well positioned to respond
-
and dynamically adjust strategy quite quickly so
-
that you are in the most sort of efficient modal
-
to respond to a very dynamic
-
Economy, which is going to be very key as we make our way
-
through the next 3, 6, 9 months.
-
It's going to be especially key
-
to not just look at a headline number,
-
but really look under the hood
-
and the nuance that is, um,
-
that is really showcasing itself in this economy
-
because that's going to be where the potential
-
for growth really lies.
-
So with that, if this is something
-
that you are interested in and you would like
-
to learn more about how board may facilitate you in doing
-
any of these things, please feel free to reach out
-
for a demo visit board com to do so.
-
And with that, I just wanna say thank you
-
for your time as always.
-
It was a pleasure.